Best Tool Bag Reviews & Buying Guide 2020

Still have no luck finding the best tool bag? Well I understand as there are a lot of tool bags crowding the market. Just do a quick Google search and you will be flooded with products. No need to worry because this is the best tool bag review guide for you.

I have years of experience using tools and tool bags so I know which ones work and which don’t. I have gone through the most popular tool bags online and from there gathered 5 of the best. It was not easy picking out, but I went through it and came out with these.

I have also prepared a buyer’s guide for those who aren’t familiar with these bags. All right, let’s get down to business.

Why You Need a Tool Bag?

We can list a lot of reasons why you need a tool bag, but we will just go through the most important reasons here.

First and foremost it allows you to carry all your needed tools to wherever you need to go. No need to make do with makeshift tools as the bags have the pockets and space. They’re also portable so even if filled with tools, you’ll still be able to carry it.

These bags also make it easy for you to organize your tools. You can then use the tool bag to speed up your work and be more productive.

A tool bag can be used by professional carpenters, electricians, construction workers and the like to be more proficient. But their use extends beyond that. A DIY enthusiast can use this to pack tools. Anyone who needs a good bag benefits too.

A tool bag can also be used for camping or anytime you’re going on the road. Unlike regular bags, they are more durable too. That is why a lot of those who buy these bags use it for other stuff.

The versatility of tool bags is one reason why a lot of people like to buy these. If you’re looking for a bag that has a lot of useful functions, this is it.

Types of Tool Bags

Tool bags are made from different materials, but the most common are cloth, leather and nylon.
Leather: This is the most expensive and the most stylish as well. Leather tool bags look good and are durable. But leather is a bit on the heavy side and is the most expensive material as well.
Nylon: Nylon is the most widely used fabric and for good reasons. It is not as costly as leather yet is durable. It is also lighter than leather so even if you fill it up with tools the bag won’t be as heavy.

Cloth: Cloth tool bags may be comprised of different materials like cotton, polyester or a combination of various fabrics. The quality and durability will depend on the cloth material used.

Of the many tool bag materials that you can choose from, nylon is the most practical and appropriate. Some tool bags use polyester as it is also one of the better materials available.

A lot of other tool bags blend different types of materials. The quality in this case will depend on what type of materials are combined. The point is you have a lot lot options.

Things to Consider Before Buying a Tool Bag

There are thousands of tool bags, so how do you find the right one of the job? You need to establish a criteria to find the appropriate one. Use the following tips to help you decide which is the appropriate tool bag.


The bigger the bag the more tools you can put inside it. However the extra size means the bag is bigger and potentially heavier. The bag may not seem too heavy now, but once it is packed with tools it is going to be a different story.

That is why it is important that you find a tool bag with the right balance. A bag that is too heavy is impractical to carry around. If the bag does not have a lot of pockets and too light, it won’t last. That is the reason why choosing the right weight is crucial.

Storage Space

How much space is in the bag? The reason you bought a tool bag is to find a home for your tools, so is there enough space here?

Check how many pockets and pouches are available. Look also for clips, loops or sleeves where you can hang your tools. Tool bags come different numbers of pockets, so it is up to you to decide how many you need.

Think not only of your current needs but also your future. If you’re going to use more tools anytime soon, better invest in a tool bag that has the space for them. The more space available the easier it will be to organize tools.


A well made tool bag must be able to meet the requirements of different users. One vital feature is the bag must have a wide mouth so you can reach in and find the tools you need. A wide mouth also makes it simple to throw in a battery pack, power tools, hand tools and other items.


Is the tool bag waterproof? Is the bag made of durable materials? The durability of the bag critical especially if you work in different locations. This is where the type of material used for the tool bag really makes a difference.

If your work requires you to head out to various locations where it’s hot, rainy, windy etc a waterproof or water resistant tool bag is necessary.

Comfort and Adjustability

A feature packed tool bag is not going to do you much good if it is uncomfortable to wear and use. Make sure the bag straps are adjustable so you’ll be able to reach for those tools when it is needed.

Customer Reviews

As you may have noticed, all tool bags make the same claim about being the best. However that is not true as some bags are better than others. One of the ways to find out how good of a bag is by reading the reviews online.

There is no no need for you to believe what the brands say, just read reviews and you’ll get a notion of how good – or bad – the tool bag is.

5 Best Tool Bags:

1. Stanley STST70574 12-Inch Soft Sided Tool Bag

The STST70574 is durable, spacious and versatile, qualities that make it a strong candidate for the best tool bag. It also comes with outer mesh pockets so you can store small tools, accessories and other items.

The bag has a rubber foam at the bottom which provides protection for the items inside. Even if there is a hard fall, the foam acts as a cushion.

The STST70574 also comes with cotton handles so you’ll feel comfortable carrying the bag. And since the strap is adjustable you can fine tune the bag’s handling.

These are just examples of the many reviews for the STST70574 that have been published online. As should be obvious, the feedback tells you a lot about its quality.


  • Comfortable to use.
  • Lots of pockets.
  • Made of solid materials.
  • Sufficient padding.
  • Adjustable.


  • Zipper quality could be better.
  • A bit smaller than other tool bags in this range.

Summary of amazon reviews

The STST70574 has received a lot of good reviews. One of those who gave the STST70574 five stars said it is ideal for storing household tools. He also mentioned in his review that the bag is made from high quality materials. Another one said it is built to last.

Another customer gave the STST70574 five stars for being affordable. He also said the bag opens and closes well. Its durability is one of its strongest points and admired by a lot of reviewers. Ease of use is a strong point too.

Another customer said the STST70574 is just the right size for the projects he works on. Another buyer said he’s very satisfied with the tool bag, noting that it is spacious and well constructed. Still another reviewer said the STST70574 is precisely what he requires.

2. CLC Custom Leather Craft 1107 2 Bag Combo

Anytime we talk about the best tool bag, the name LeatherCraft comes up as they make some really good bags. This 2 bag combo is one of their better offers.

These are durable all around bags made for contractors, painters, carpenters, electricians and anyone who carries a lot of tools around. The bag’s bottom panels have been fortified to deal with extended use.

With a large and medium bag, you’ll be able to store more tools and be more productive. The bag also makes it easier to organize your supplies to be more accessible no matter where you work.


  • Both bags are durable.
  • Lots of space.
  • Ergonomic handles.
  • Makes organizing tools easy.
  • Fortified construction.


  • No small pockets in the bag.
  • A sawzall cannot fit in the large bag.

Summary of amazon reviews

The feedback for the LeatherCraft 1107 has been generally favorable. A customer awarded the bags 5 stars, saying he’s ale to fit a lot of tools and supplies in it. Another one said the 1107 has been able to take a lot of punishment.

A lot of the 5 star ratings have expressed satisfaction with its durability. One of those who bought the bag said he’s impressed by the construction.

One of the customers who bought the 1107 said it’s fantastic for motorcycle use. The reviewer said it’s light and comfortable even when packed.

Many customers who buy the tool bag use it for other stuff. One reviewer said he’s used it to carry first aid kits, cameras, phones, energy bars and other items.

As these reviews show, the general consensus is that the 1107 bags are versatile, ideal for professionals and anyone who wants a spacious, quality bag.

3. Craftsman 9-37535 Soft Tool Bag, 13"

The 9-37535 is billed as an all around tool bag, and this best tool bag review can say it’s true. It comes with 6 pockets, three regular and three mesh for easier organization of tools and supplies.

The bag is built for heavy duty use, and this is indicated by the reinforced bottom. Even when exposed to the elements, the 9-37535 holds up just fine.

The bag opens up wide so you can easily put items in it. Closing the bag is just as easy so you’ll be ready to go on the road anytime.


  • Plenty of pockets.
  • Fortified stress points.
  • Comfortable handle.
  • Solidly built.
  • Provides interior protection.


  • Not big enough for 2 ATV helmets.
  • No rubber feet.

Summary of amazon reviews

The 9-37535 has gotten several reviews, and most of the customers like what they’re getting. The reviews here should give you an idea of what the feedback has been like.

One of those gave the bag 5 stars for being spacious. This is also what another reviewer said, pointing out he’s now able to carry all the essential tools and supplies.

A quick look at the reviews show that most customers like the bag’s space. She said it was a gift for her fiance who’s very satisfied with it. One buyer wrote a short review saying it’s just what he wanted.

One satisfied customer said the bag is just what he doctor ordered. He said it has lots of space and convenient to use. Another customer shared a similar opinion.

As the reviews here indicate, the 9-37535 does not disappoint when it comes to performance and capacity. Both new and long time buyers of the brand express satisfaction with the product and how it works.

4. DeWalt 18 in. Pro Contractor's Closed Top Tool Bag

The Pro Collector from Dewalt has 28 exterior pockets and 14 interior. The exterior pockets also have 3 pockets with flap covers, while the interiors have one that’s zippered.

The best tool bag should offer plenty of storage solutions, and the Pro Collector does. It has a tape measure clip and a pocket knife holder too.

Its shoulder strap is easy to adjust too. Lastly the bag is made from ballistic poly fabric with bottom protection pads. With several pockets and storage options, you’ll have greater flexibility for organization and usage.


  • Several pockets.
  • Long lasting fabrics.
  • Heavy duty zipper.
  • Easy to adjust.
  • Utility knife pocket included.


  • Slightly heavier than other bags.
  • Thin shoulder strap padding.

Summary of amazon reviews

The Pro Collector has received a lot of good reviews. Majority of those who gave it 5 stars say it’s of good quality and durable.

A happy customer gave it 5 stars, saying it is durable and good for all around use. One customer simply stated it’s an ideal tool bag and gave 5 stars too. One buyer emphasized it’s sturdy and heavy too.

A long time Dewalt user said the bag is solidly built and up to par with the other Dewalt products. A customer also wrote a detailed review where he said it’s a good tool bag and worth the money.

One of those who purchased the Pro Collector said it is good for the price. He also said the multiple pockets add to its functionality. Someone who purchased the tool bag also said it’s made of tough material.

There are many more reviews online, but this should suffice to give you an idea of how it is being received.

​5. WORKPRO 2-Piece 13-inch & 18-inch Tool Bag Combo

The WorkPro 2 bag combo has 6 pockets, three regular exterior and three mesh. Using these you can quickly organize your tools and whatever items you want to put in the bag.

The bag’s handles make the WorkPro 2 bag combo easy to carry. Both of the bags are solidly made and can handle exposure to the elements.

The bag has interior compartments that make organizing simpler. And since these are two bags you can place a lot more items in it. You can also use both bags or just one depending on your needs.


  • You get 2 bags.
  • Fortified construction.
  • Deep pockets.
  • Wide opening.
  • Smooth zippers.


  • Handles feel a bit flimsy.
  • Clasp is a little hard to open.

Summary of amazon reviews

The WorkPro 2 bag combo has a lot of positive reviews and compares well with other expensive products. One of the customers who bought the bag said it’s the most durable he’s tried.

One very happy customer said he’s so happy he bought four of them. Another one said the combo bags are well worth the price. This is also the view of another customer who said the bags have a lot of uses.

A very happy customer said the bag is as good as advertised and that he had no complaints. One buyer said he didn’t expect to get two quality bags so she’s satisfied with the purchase.

One of those who bought the 2 bags wrote that they’re top quality. The reviewer also stated the bags are among the best that he has tried. He also said the zippers, pockets and other elements are just as good. The bottom line is that these combo bags are exceptionally well made.

Advantages of Tool Bags:

As the best tool bag review can tell you, there are a lot of reasons why it pays to have one of these.

  • A tool bag is very convenient. When you have one of these, you can pack all the tools and supplies you need.
  • A tool bag makes it easy to keep yourself organized. With several pockets, pouches and compartments you can separate the items.
  • A tool bag is light and makes it easy to carry around.
  • These have been fortified so it can handle extended use.
  • A tool bag is versatile. While they’re made for storing tools, you can just as easily use this for cameras, gadgets and other items you’ll need.
  • These bags have an ergonomic design so you’ll feel comfortable even if the bag is full.
  • These bags are very accessible and last a long time.

Take Care of Your Tool Bag:

No best tool bag review will be complete without a taking care of guide. Keep the following in mind to make the most out of that bag.

  • Clean the bag on a regular basis. However you should only use cleaning materials that are suitable for the material.
  • Don’t put any sharp objects in the bag pointed down unless it has a sheath.
  • Don’t wash the bag incessantly. Just wipe the dust and dirt off. Use a damp cloth if the dirt won’t come off.
  • Store the bag in safe, dry location. Tool bags are meant for heavy duty use, but it won’t hurt to safely store them.
  • Arrange the tools as you see fit, but don’t use the tool bag for stuff it is not meant to do.
  • Inspect the bag for signs of wear and tear. Fix the bag immediately if there are problems or buy a new one.
  • Don’t use a damaged tool bag as it could rip apart while you’re using it.
  • Don’t let dust and dirt accumulate as it makes the bag harder to clean.

Final Words:

Whether you’re a carpenter, DIY enthusiast, plumber or electrician, having a high quality tool bag is a must. One of the problems before is the difficulty in figuring out which one is ideal. That is the reason why I created this guide, to help you figure out which one to buy.

After going through the reviews, you are now in the right position to pick out the right product. All the 5 tool bags here are built for the long term so you won’t be disappointed with any of them. Even if you have never bought any before, this best tool bag guide is going to make sure you get your money’s worth.

Share this Story
Load More Related Articles
Load More By Andrew C. Dyer
  • Bag

    Best Tool Bag Reviews & Buying Guide 2020

    Still have no luck finding the best tool bag? Well I understand as there are a lot of tool bags crowding ...
Load More In Bag

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Check Also

How to Install a Truck Tool Box?

So you’ve finally got that truck tool box, ...